Defining Horror, with Dan Pinchbeck

‘Defining Horror’ is our new series that explores the creative minds behind the horror games that we love. Each entry in the series will share new aspects of the creative process, shining light on a developer’s idea of what makes a quality horror experience, what elements are integral to a horror game, as well as what goes into effectively making an impact on the player. ‘Defining Horror’ is a series that aims to give gamers insight into what the horror genre means to those who have developed or are developing horror games.

Below you will find Dan Pinchbeck’s definition of horror.

Name: Dan Pinchbeck
Company: The Chinese Room
Title: Creative Director of The Chinese Room
Past Projects: Dear Esther, DOOM: Scarydarkfast
Current Projects: Amnesia: A Machine for Pigs, Everybody’s Gone to the Rapture

An exclusive screenshot of Amnesia: A Machine for Pigs

Horror is about the player. Everything else is irrelevant. Historically, horror games got sidetracked quickly into resource management as being a relatively easy way of introducing anxiety into play. But that’s not true, proper horror – that’s tension and anxiety and they are different things. They work alongside horror and fear, sure, but they are different and distinct and that’s important to remember.

True horror is story driven. True horror is about what isn’t represented, it’s about co-opting the player’s own imagination, it’s about the emotional landscape of their immersion in the game. The most frightening moments in games are not mechanic driven, they are driven by atmosphere and the space and time for a player’s imagination to fester and erupt into terrifying new forms. This is what Frictional understood so brilliantly with The Dark Descent. the first hour of that game is not terrifying because of not having any tinder boxes, or some visual FX to suggest you are going a bit nuts. It’s terrifying because of what is missing. And what is missing is a monster. The lack of actual stimulation, this incredibly light gameplay in technical terms creates a fucking nightmare playground for your imagination, because you start creating your own monsters to fill this yawning gulf of stimulus. The best part of Dead Space 2, the return to the Ishimura, works for exactly the same reason. Ghosts and Dead City are the standout sections of Metro 2033 and Last Light. Exactly the same principle. When it all starts going down in a game, you shift emphasis from imagination to solutions. Horror isn’t about solutions, it’s about inaction. When you have a player too terrified to even press a key, to have the game progress, then you’ve absolutely nailed it.

One of my biggest inspirations as a writer is the Hemingway short story: “For sale. Baby’s shoes. Never Worn.” It’s a work of genius, because in six words, he creates a catalyst for imagination in a powerful and deep way. Great horror games work with a similar principle. Just enough gameplay, just enough story, just enough system to engage, then hand over the work of creating terror to the player’s imagination. Never show or tell too much. Never expose the mechanics of the ghost train. Never let them off with a simple explanation. Never think you can outpace the player’s imagination in terms of generating fear.

- Dan Pinchbeck

  • Fabian

    Aww brings me back to the old golden days of silent hill. That radio going off but both the monster and my vision are obscured by the thick blanket of fog. Same thing for when it was dark. Surrounded by darkness the only light being that small circle coming from the flashlight.

  • drachehexe

    I think his take on the matter is dead on. What you think is out there can often be worse than what’s actually out there and if the game can build up that in the player than that’s better than any monster. And his statement “Never show or tell too much. Never expose the mechanics of the ghost train. Never let them off with a simple explanation” is to me the most important part. It’s like learning how the magicians illusion is done, once you know how it works the magic is gone.

    • http://relyonhorror.com/ CJ Melendez

      We’ve got some pretty awesome people contributing! It’s not a competition, but there’s bound to be some differences and unique views from each and every person.

  • DarkDreamT2

    Definitely a great take on it. Part of what made the Fatal Frame series so terrifying was the knowledge that, due to the nature of your enemies, anything could happen at any time, yet most of the time nothing did. The nothingness that goes on starts getting to you because you already know how they work. The music changes from place to place, and the sudden stop of music in some locations definitely adds to the tension. And as soon as you kind of get adjusted to it, something unexpected happens and ruins your sense of security.

  • Ahmad Al-Hamily

    The story is the beef and everything else adds to the excitement. I’m in agreement with Dan. Steering the emotions makes for a great horror experience title and I have played several games that gave me the creeps and shivers simply by being immersed and wondering what is what.

    One example is when visiting the hellish version of Midwitch elementary school. I was imaging drawings of demons on the walls of the corridors though I’m sure it was just my imagination.

    Really enjoyed the article and looking forward to the next one.